Player ratings: Hanging tough

New Zealand were slightly off the standards they normally set for themselves, but still managed to hang tough and secure a win.


Despite the best efforts of the French to upset them, the All Blacks held on in the face of a fierce late rally for a 26-19 win in Paris.


The two tries to one win is as close as the game was - just one converted try in it.


Jan de Koning rates the New Zealand players!


15 Israel Dagg:

Stats will suggest that he made plenty of metres with ball in hand, but is wasn't ass effective as he can be and he also missed a couple of tackles.

5/10


14 Cory Jane:

Came close early in the game, but thereafter saw very little action. Made a couple of decent tackles.

5/10


13 Ben Smith:

Solid on defence, but struggled to impose himself in midfield - maybe he is just a fullback/wing.

5/10


12 Ma'a Nonu:

Injected himself into the game early on, but made a couple of handling errors and missed as many tackles as he made.

4/10


11 Charles Piutau:

Struggled on defence and was easily beaten on a couple of occasions, but showed his pace to score first try and produced a great offload for Kieran Read's try.

6/10


10 Daniel Carter:

May have slipped a few tackles, but was a class act - as always.

7/10


9 Aaron Smith:

Did a lot of kicking from the base and his passing was crisp. Missed just one tackle.

6/10


8 Kieran Read:

Was a huge factor in the game - plenty of tackles, scored a crucial try, won his line-outs and even stole a crucial ball on the French throw.

9/10


7 Richie McCaw (captain):

Was caught out and penalised at the breakdown a few times, but produced an enormous tackle count - the second highest in the game.

7/10


6 Liam Messam:

Penalised a couple of times and also missed a few tackles, but still worked hard.

6/10


5 Samuel Whitelock:

Made enough tackles and won a couple of line-outs, but involved in some silly off-the-ball stuff late in the game.

6/10


4 Brodie Retallick:

Early penalty for playing a man off the ball, but after that produced an enormous defensive effort - 17 tackles. Also won a vital line-out steal.

8/10


3 Owen Franks:

Went down in the first scrum and the popped up in the next and was later penalised again. His workrate can also improve.

5/10


2 Keven Mealamu:

Was caught offside a couple of times close to his line - in true Kiwi tradition giving away three points rather than five or seven. Made a handful of tackles.

6/10


1 Tony Woodcock:

Not sure what value he adds outside of the scrums - missed as many tackles as he made, four.

4/10


Replacements:


16 Dane Coles (on for Mealamu, 60th min):

Again showed up to be a lightweight and was bowled over on defence a couple of times.

4/10


17 Wyatt Crockett (on for Woodcock, 69th min):

His usual collection of penalties - still the most penalised prop in world rugby. Not long enough to be rated.


18 Charlie Faumuina (on for Franks, 53rd min):

Other than a few tackles added no real value.

5/10


19 Steven Luatua:

Not used.


20 Sam Cane:

Not used.


21 Tawera Kerr-Barlow (on for AL Smith, 71st min):

Not enough time to be rated.


22 Aaron Cruden (on for Carter, 52nd min):

He struggled to maintain the same momentum that Carted gave the All Blacks.

5/10


23 Ryan Crotty (on for Jane, 69th min):

Not enough time to be rated.